Is it Better to Hire a Professional Tile Setter or a DIY Tile Replacement?

Posted on February 19, 2024

img

DIY Fixes or Professional Replacement: Decoding Tile Dilemmas
A new tile design can breathe fresh life into any space, from a dull bathroom floor to an outdated kitchen backsplash. However, most homeowners' dilemma with tile replacement is whether to opt for professional tile setters or go for the DIY method. 
 
Both choices have their fors and againsts. That is why, with this blog, we will help you understand both approaches so you can choose which method will suit you more. Let us begin!
Beginning with the DIY Tile Replacement Approach! 
The idea of tackling home improvement projects yourself can be irresistible to DIY enthusiasts. DIY tile replacement offers the opportunity for hands-on creativity, cost savings, and provides you with a sense of accomplishment. 
 
The biggest backing for DIY projects is the use of online tutorials, YouTube videos, and a willingness to learn. Unfortunately, installing or replacing tile yourself is much harder than you expect, especially if it is your first time. 
Process of DIY Tile Replacement

The following process will help you comprehend what goes into the process of DIY tile replacement:
 
  1. Assessing the Situation
Begin by assessing the area where you wish to replace the tiles. Determine if they are cracked, chipped, or loose or if you just wish to install a new tile design. Measure and get the exact specifics for the space where the replacement needs to be done. 
 
  1. Gathering Materials and Tools
Once you have the space dimensions, you can check and order new tiles that match the specifics of your existing space. Other than that, you need to gather the following tools for the project:  
 
  • Hammer 
  • Chisel
  • Putty knife
  • Grout saw
  • Tile adhesive or mortar, 
  • Grout 
  • Grout float
  • Sponge
  • Gloves
 
  1. Removing Damaged Tiles
 
  • Using a grout saw, carefully remove the grout around the damaged tiles. 
  • Place a chisel at the edge of the tile and gently tap it with a hammer to break it.
  • Use a putty knife or a scraper to remove the broken pieces or adhesive from the surface.
 
  1. Preparing the Substrate
Clean the substrate to remove any dust, debris, or old adhesive. Ensure it's dry and smooth before proceeding.
 
  1. Installing Replacement Tiles
 
  • Apply a thin layer of tile adhesive to the back of the replacement tile using a notched trowel.
  • Press the tiles firmly into place and flush them one by one with the surrounding tiles.
  • Use tile spacers to maintain consistent spacing between tiles.
  • Allow the adhesive to dry. 
 
  1. Grouting the Tiles
 
  • Mix grout as per the manufacturer's instructions once the adhesive has dried.
  • Use a grout float to apply grout to the joints between the tiles by pressing it firmly into place.
  • Remove excess grout from the tile surface using a damp sponge.
 
  1. Cleaning and Finishing
 
  • Allow the grout to cure for the recommended time.
  • Buff the tiles with a clean and dry cloth to remove any haze.
  • Seal the grout with a grout sealer to protect it from moisture and stains.

The Pitfalls of DIY Tile Installation
Although the idea of DIY tile installation sounds appealing, there are many significant challenges and limitations associated with this approach. Here are some of them:
 
  • Tile installation demands precision and expertise at every step, from substrate preparation to grouting.
  • Lack of experience and specialized tools can hinder DIYers from achieving professional-quality results.
  • Common issues in DIY tile installation include misaligned tiles, uneven grout lines, and improper waterproofing.
  • Mistakes in DIY tile projects can lead to costly repairs or complete replacement, adding to unnecessary expenses. 
Leveraging Professional Tile Setters for Tile Replacement
In contrast to the DIY approach, professional tile setters may seem a costlier approach. However, expert tile contractors bring a wealth of experience, expertise, and efficiency to the table. 
 
They offer numerous benefits that can elevate your project from ordinary to extraordinary, such as: 
 
  1. Expertise, Experience, and Precision
Professional tile setters possess specialized knowledge and skills. They ensure higher precision and high-quality tile replacement results.
 
  1. Efficiency and Time Savings
Expert tile contractors work efficiently, completing projects in less time than DIY efforts and minimizing disruption to your schedule.
 
  1. Quality Assurance and Warranty
Reputable tile setters offer warranties and guarantees. This helps in assuring durable and long-lasting tile installations.
 
  1. Access to Resources
Professional tile setters have better access to high-quality materials, tools, and suppliers. This helps in ensuring optimal results for your project.
 
  1. Guaranteed Workmanship
With professional tile setters, you can trust in their expertise and commitment to delivering impeccable workmanship every time.

Take Your Pick: DIY Fixing or Professional Replacement!

Deciding between DIY tile fixing and hiring professional tile setters depends on your skills, budget, and project needs. While DIY tile installation is more cost-effective, it carries inherent risks and challenges. On the contrary, expert tile contractors provide higher efficiency and superior results backed by expertise and warranty. So, it is for you to decide which option suits you the best. Good Luck!
 
Find Tile Contractors in Orange County!

Share this Post